Prompts

A chat assistant for writing: what it does well and where it slips

We spent a month writing news, emails and posts with an assistant. Here is where it saves time and where it adds work.

For you: Hand the assistant the grunt work, check the facts yourself, and you can free up about an hour a day.

A chat assistant for writing: what it does well and where it slips
A chat assistant for writing: what it does well and where it slips

promptYou are an editor's assistant. Task: [cut the text in half / suggest five headlines / rewrite the letter in plain words]. Context: [who, where, which job title, which date — exact details]. Text: [text]. Rules: do not a…

Chat assistants for writing are now on every phone. They draft emails, shorten texts and come up with headlines. But there is a gap between "it will write everything for me" and how the work actually goes.

We spent a month writing news, emails and posts with an assistant. We wanted to see where it really helps and where it adds work instead. The answer is simple: the assistant is a good helper but a poor source.

What it does well

The assistant is best at the grunt work. We used it most for three tasks.

  1. Halving a text. Give it a long news story or report and it keeps the main point while cutting repetition. Say in the prompt what must stay: numbers, names, quotes.
  2. Suggesting five headlines. When one text needs several options, the assistant is quick. Out of five, one usually works straight away and another needs a small edit.
  3. Rewriting a formal letter in plain words. It turns long, heavy sentences into clear text. That helps when you write to a client or explain a rule to readers.

All three tasks have something in common: no new facts are needed. The assistant works with existing text and changes only its form. This is where it is most reliable.

Where it slips

It is weaker on facts and local context. We saw three mistakes more often than others.

  • It mixes up job titles. The person's name may be right while the title belongs to someone else.
  • It invents dates. If the text has no date, the assistant may "fill one in", and it looks believable.
  • It knows little about Kazakhstan. Agency names, local rules, events in cities — unless you put them in the prompt, it writes something vague or wrong.

The reason is clear. The model learned from a huge amount of text, but there is less about Kazakhstan in it than about global topics. And when a fact is missing, the model does not say "I don't know" — it writes a likely option. So the mistake arrives in a confident tone and is hard to spot.

All of this adds work. If one job title in an email drafted by the assistant is wrong, you have to reread the whole text to find it.

Our newsroom rule

After a month we settled on a simple rule: the assistant drafts, a person checks every name, number and quote.

In practice it looks like this:

  • the assistant shortens the text, suggests headlines, simplifies the letter;
  • the writer marks every name, title, date, number and quote in the draft;
  • each one is checked against the original text, an official website or the person themselves;
  • nothing unchecked stays in the text.

With this routine, each writer saves about an hour a day. Time is freed from routine, while checking stays with a person. Without the rule the savings disappear fast: one published mistake takes more time to fix than was saved.

A prompt that cuts down mistakes

You cannot remove the assistant's mistakes entirely, but you can reduce them. Give the context yourself and forbid new facts:

You are an editor's assistant. Task: [cut the text in half / suggest five headlines / rewrite the letter in plain words].
Context: [who, where, which job title, which date — exact details].
Text: [text].
Rules: do not add facts that are not in the text or the context. Do not change names, job titles, dates, numbers or quotes. If something is missing, do not guess — ask a question at the end.

What to fill in: pick one task, put every exact detail into the context — especially anything about Kazakhstan — and paste the full text.

How to check the answer:

  1. Compare every name and title in the draft with your context.
  2. If a date or number appears that is not in your context, remove it.
  3. Read the questions at the end — they show what you forgot to include.

Variations:

  • For a post: "Task: turn this text into a three-sentence social media post."
  • For a letter: add "Tone: polite but not formal."
  • Short version: Cut this text in half. Keep every name, number and quote unchanged.

What this means for you, and what to do today

Students, journalists and business owners all write every day. The assistant can take over the longest part of that work, but not the responsibility. Be especially careful with it on facts about Kazakhstan.

Steps you can start with today:

  1. Pick three tasks you repeat every week: shortening, headlines, emails.
  2. Save the prompt above and fill in the context block every time.
  3. In every draft, mark and check names, titles, dates, numbers and quotes.
  4. Note which tasks the assistant gets wrong most often. After a week you will know where not to use it.
Ad Your ad hereA banner on the homepage, in stories and sections. Formats and prices on our Advertise page.

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first.